Saturday, June 23, 2007

Rules for Aging Rock Stars

I've had an ongoing project to listen through all of my music collection over the next few years (which is much easier now that I have an iPod that holds it all), and while listening yesterday a few thoughts came to me regarding "Greatest Hits" albums:

1. Never publish a "Greatest Hits" album while you're still actively recording. It would seem this is common sense--since only time and distance will tell what your biggest hits are--but few artists seem to follow this principle. Also, since we often don't know when we've peaked and should pack it in, the corollary would be...
1a. Never publish a "Greatest Hits" album while you're alive.

2. Never--under any circumstances--should there be a "Greatest Hits--Volume II". By definition, these are not greatest hits--just the best of what's left.

3. No more than three songs from any given album should be on a "Greatest Hits" collection. If your career doesn't support the four or five albums that would be required to fill a standard-length CD, feel free to save us time and money by producing an "EP".

4. A "Greatest Hits" album is not a vehicle for new content. Don't force us to listen to your new stuff while re-living the past, and don't force us to buy your old stuff if we want the latest single.